Anish Giri shared his opinion on Hikaru Nakamura’s playstyle in an interview with Chess with Mustreader. Giri says that Nakamura’s games lack a logical thread of sequence. Anish notes that Hikaru belongs to a different school of chess than he does.

Anish Giri

Anish Giri

Netherlands' No. 1

“Hikaru has such a different philosophy of chess. Personally, for example, I really understand and admire how Denis Lazavik plays. The way he sets up a game, how he approaches it all, his playing style, his opening choices, the way he prepares on such a grand scale…

If a person looks at all of this on such a grand scale and prepares so thoroughly for everything, it shapes certain qualities. And, of course, Denis’s play looks completely different from Hikaru’s.

Hikaru belongs to a different school of chess than I do. And honestly, when I look at his play, I don’t like it at all, to be perfectly frank. I just don’t like it.

I’m not saying he plays badly. I remember when he won Tata Steel Chess India 2018. And I was commenting on the games for New in Chess magazine. I had to comment on one of his games.

He won a huge number of games there. And they told me: ‘Commentate on one of Hikaru’s games’. I filtered through his games and started reviewing them to choose which one to commentate on.

In the end, I went through all the games, and I just didn’t know which one to pick to comment on. They were so, how should I put it, unappealing…

[Question: Can you explain in more detail what exactly you don’t like?]

I guess I like it when there’s some kind of logical thread running through a game. Because the books I grew up on were commentaries by the great chess players of the past. They didn’t have computers, after all, and they always thought that a game generally followed a straight path.

And I guess I got the impression, like a beginner chess player, that that’s how you’re supposed to play chess. That there’s, so to speak, a logic to the struggle. Of course, there are sometimes blunders, but by and large, if you take those blunders out, the game follows a straight logical path.

But in Hikaru’s games, even at a glance, it’s clear that there was a struggle… The thread I’m used to seeing is missing from the game. There are also certain aesthetic aspects…

There are the objective factors of chess aesthetics. A position can be beautiful or unattractive. This is influenced by Pawn structure, weak squares, poorly placed pieces, and so on.

And many chess players really dislike playing unaesthetically. For example, you will rarely see Magnus with a Bishop on ‘e3’. But you will much more often find this in Hikaru’s games. I am almost certain that Hikaru has had many more positions of this kind than Magnus. Because, basically, he doesn’t really care about that.

As a result, Nakamura has more of these games. Not always, of course, there are exceptions. Sometimes Magnus has bad luck with a Bishop, and sometimes Hikaru plays a brilliant positional game.

But rarely. Hikaru has far fewer of them.”

Hikaru Nakamura is currently World’s No. 3 with 2794.2 Classical points. Nakamura’s best rank is World’s No. 2 and his peak rating is 2816.

Credit: Lennart Ootes